Choose this system if you enjoy being in control and love learning new DIY skills. It works great for hands-on RVers. However, if you prioritize pure convenience and stability, skip it. You will miss your black water tank by day three.
3 situations where you might regret it:
- You hate maintenance and don't have the patience to develop "correct usage habits."
- Your vehicle's space and ventilation are difficult to manage (especially in small campers).
- You want it to "work like a home toilet," but don't want to take on the extra cleaning and management.
If you frowned at point 2, you're likely better suited to a "lower-maintenance" alternative.
Camper Composting Toilet: Is Composting Right for You?
(30-Second Self-Assessment)
Here's a straightforward self-assessment, 10 points total, the higher the score, the better suited you are to composting:
- Can you accept a system that requires regular management/maintenance? (0–2)
- Are you willing to follow the usage rules (e.g., keeping it dry, operating according to instructions)? (0–2)
- Can your vehicle provide adequate ventilation (or are you willing to make modifications)? (0–2)
- Do you frequently boondock/find it inconvenient to find dump stations? (0–2)
- Are you more concerned with "reducing reliance on black water tanks" than "using it as freely as a home toilet"? (0–2)
Scoring:
- 0–4 points: Don't force yourself to use composting; you'll regret it.
- 5–7 points: You can consider it, but choose and install carefully.
- 8–10 points: A composting toilet is a great fit for you; you'll find it easier to use over time.
RV Composting Toilet How It Works: How Does It Actually Work?
The core of a composting toilet isn't "mysterious composting," but three key principles: dry, ventilated, and separated:
- Separation (common): Separating liquids and solids as much as possible to reduce moisture and odor risks.
- Ventilation: Continuously removing moisture and odors (usually via a fan + exhaust).
- Maintaining dryness: Keeping the solid portion as dry and manageable as possible through media materials, stirring, and proper usage habits.
Blackwater tank systems are "mixing everything together and treating it centrally"; composting systems are "trying to prevent it from becoming a mess and managing it separately."
A composting toilet is more like "equipment + process," not "buy it, put it there, and it automatically works."
Composting Toilet for Rv Pros and Cons: Real Advantages and Disadvantages
| Dimension | Composting Toilet Pros | Composting Toilet Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Off-grid Capability | Reduces the frequency of looking for dump stations. | Maintenance still exists; it’s just a different method. |
| Odor Control | If ventilation and drying are done well, the experience is very clean. | If done poorly, it becomes a "humidity management hell." |
| Water Dependency | Much lower water pressure (some systems require almost no flushing). | User experience may not be as intuitive as "flush and forget." |
| System Complexity | Eliminates the traditional black water tank setup. | Requires ventilation, power (usually for fans), and specific installation layouts. |
| Long-term Cost | Not necessarily high; depends on your usage habits. | Time costs are often underestimated (cleaning/maintenance/learning habits). |
| Psychological Barrier | A big plus for "eco-friendly/self-sufficient" enthusiasts. | Very discouraging for those who "just want things to be easy." |
Composting Toilet in Camper: Installation Points
This section won't teach you which screws to tighten (that's for a separate tutorial), but will tell you the key points you must confirm before installation, because these determine whether you'll regret your purchase.
1. Space and seat height: Don't let "comfort" turn into "numb legs"
- Clearly measure the available area and the opening/turning path.
- Pay attention to seat height, front and back space, and sitting angle (especially in small campers).
2. Ventilation route:
You need to consider:
- Where can the exhaust vent go?
- Will it involve many bends?
- Can you avoid rainwater backflow/reflux?
- Can you accept drilling holes in the vehicle body?
The smoother the ventilation, the less trouble you'll have later. The more awkward the ventilation, the more you'll think, "Why do I smell that odor again?"
3. Power supply:
Many composting systems require the fan to run continuously or frequently. It may not consume electricity, but you need to ensure:
- Stable power supply
- Safe wiring
- You don't "let yourself go" because you're too lazy to turn on the fan (and then blame the system for not working properly)
4. Mounting method: Mobility = Trouble Multiplier
The bumps and vibrations of RV travel can amplify many "small problems." Unstable mounting, loose structures, and worn interfaces can all exponentially increase maintenance difficulty.
How Much Does a Composting Toilet Cost? How Are the Costs Broken Down?
Mainstream brand range: $600 – $1,200.
- Nature's Head / Air Head: Approximately $1,030 - $1,100.
- Separett Tiny / Villa: Approximately $989 - $999.
- Entry-level/Simple models (e.g., Trelino): Approximately $399 - $629.
- DIY solution: Bucket + urine separator, as low as $50 - $100.
Installation surcharges:
- Material costs: Ventilation pipes, sealant, 12V wire connectors, etc., approximately $50 - $150.
- Labor costs: If you hire a professional technician, you will need to pay an additional $400 - $1,300 (depending on whether rewiring is needed).
Total Cost = Equipment + Installation & Modification + Long-Term Consumables + Your Time Cost
1. One-Time Costs
- Equipment itself (models vary greatly)
- Installation materials/ventilation components/power supply
- If you install it yourself: Tools and trial-and-error costs
- If you hire someone to install it: Labor and modification fees
2. Long-Term Costs
- Media/cleaning/maintenance supplies
- More importantly: Your invested "maintenance time" (Some find this enjoyable, some find it torture).
3. Opportunity Cost:
The trouble with black water tanks is "centralized disposal"; the trouble with composting is "daily management". Which type of trouble do you dislike more?
Six factors for the best composting toilet for RVs
- Space compatibility: Size, seat height, and RV layout
- Ventilation compatibility: How difficult is the exhaust path, and can you accept modifications?
- Capacity and usage frequency: Does it match the number of users and frequency of use?
- Maintenance difficulty: Is cleaning easy, and can you consistently follow the rules?
- Noise and power consumption: Are you sensitive to continuous fan noise?
- Travel style: Are you a "fixed campsite type" or a "traveling around type"?
About RV Composting Toilet Reviews
① Consistency of scenarios
- Full-time negative reviews: If bloggers complain about emptying urine too often.
- Weekend positive reviews: Short-term travelers saying "there's no smell" has limited reference value for continuous use.
② Maintenance attitude
- Look for real malfunctions: Motor burnout or stirring rod breakage.
- Look for "human error": Complaints about "worms" or "foul odors" are mostly due to improper control.
③ Installation Environment
- Ventilation Path: Check for mentions of "condensate backflow" or "leaking at the drilled hole."
FAQ
Do composting toilets smell in an RV?
Depends on ventilation, humidity control, and habits. Done well, it's clean; done poorly, it's a consistent disaster.
How often do you empty an RV composting toilet?
Depends on users, frequency, and capacity. "Rhythm management" is more important than the exact number of days.
Conclusion
Composting toilets offer "off-grid freedom" in exchange for "daily meticulous management." However, if you want to get rid of the black water tank but don't want to be burdened with chores, the Modiwell dry flush toilet is clearly a more convenient alternative.
Related Articles
Dry Flush vs Composting vs Cassette Toilets -Which One Wins for RV Life?
How Does a Composting Toilet Works？
California Composting and Plastic Toilet Bag Regulations Explained
